Over one in 10 (11%) Brits aged 55+ have either already accessed their retirement pots to deal with the effects of coronavirus or intend to do so, according to investment platform AJ Bell.
The survey was conducted on a sample of 2,002 adults in the UK by market research firm Opinium between 24 and 27 April 2020.
This follows the figures released by the government showing that more than one million people have been enrolled in its furlough scheme.
Tom Selby, senior analyst at AJ Bell, said: “The covid-19 shutdown is hitting the finances of millions of people. In such difficult times, it is inevitable many over 55s will turn to their retirement pot to plug an income shortfall.
“Our research suggests one in 10 have either already done this or plan to do so – and we are only five weeks into lockdown.”
Beware of the consequences
But Selby warns that there are implications for doing so.
“Firstly, you will trigger the money purchase annual allowance (MPAA), reducing the amount most people can save in a pension each year from £40,000 ($49,764, €45,909) to just £4,000.
“Secondly, if you’re planning to take a regular income early, you will need to think about the sustainability of your withdrawal plan.
“As an example, someone taking a 5% inflation-adjusted income from their fund who experiences a 20% drop in the value of their fund in the first year of drawdown – as many have recently – could see their money run out after 18 years.
“Given many people can expect to live well into their 90s, such a withdrawal plan would risk being unsustainable even for someone who started in their mid-to-late 60s, let alone before your 60th birthday.”
Retirement choices
Retirees should be aware of the current market and fund devaluations before accessing their pensions, as this could impact their future income.
Selby continued: “Hundreds of thousands of savers access their pension for the first time every year, with the majority of those entering drawdown citing getting their 25% tax-free cash as the main reason for doing so.
“In order to access your tax-free cash, you need to ‘crystallise’ your pension – this just means choosing a retirement income route, such as drawdown or buying an annuity.
“If you choose drawdown then once you have taken 25% of your fund as tax-free cash, the remaining drawdown fund continues to benefit from any investment growth.
“However, if you crystallise your entire fund you have taken all the tax-free cash you can from that fund – you can’t go back and take more if the drawdown fund grows.
“With the FTSE100 down over 20% since the start of the year, millions of people with pensions will have seen the value of their funds plummet. Anyone choosing to access their tax-free cash today risks ‘selling on the dip’.
“For someone with a £100,000 fund who saw this drop by 20% to £80,000 during the current crisis, this would mean a fall of £5,000 in their maximum available tax-free cash – from £25,000 to £20,000,” he added.
One foot in two shoes
A middle ground option is available, however, as over 55s can opt for a partial crystallisation, Selby said.
“For those who have exhausted other ways to raise money and need to access some tax-free cash earlier than planned as a result of covid-19, ‘partial crystallisation’ is one way of mitigating the impact on your overall tax-free cash entitlement.
“If someone with a £100,000 fund wanted to access just £10,000 tax-free cash, they could choose to crystallise £40,000 of their fund rather than the entire amount, giving them the £10,000 tax-free cash they need.
“The remaining £30,000 drawdown fund and the £60,000 ‘uncrystallised’ part of the fund – including the remaining tax-free cash entitlement – would have the opportunity to grow over time.
“Another option is to take an ad-hoc lump sum from your fund, with 25% of each withdrawal tax-free.
But Selby warns that “the rest of your withdrawal will be taxed in the same way as income, and you will automatically trigger the MPAA, reducing the amount most people can save in a pension each year from £40,000 to £4,000.”
Keep topping up your fund
Even though there is no turning back once a pension is crystallised, people can still contribute to their retirement – and this could make up for the cash taken out earlier on.
“Furthermore, provided you haven’t taken taxable income from your drawdown fund and triggered the MPAA, your annual allowance in most cases will still be £40,000,” Selby said.
“If someone with a £100,000 fund accessed all their available tax-free cash at age 55 but then continued saving £3,000 a year into a pension, their new contributions could deliver a fund worth £47,000 by age 66, including a tax-free cash entitlement of £11,750.
“If they upped their annual contribution to £5,000, the new fund could be worth £78,000, with £19,500 available tax-free,” he added.
AJ Bell’s figures were calculated on the assumption of 4% real investment growth per year.
Don’t forget to review goals
Tapping into a retirement pot may not necessarily change the investment strategy of the pension fund, since many over 50s won’t access what’s left for a good decade or more.
But Selby suggests that reviewing retirement plans at this stage can optimise what people want to get out of their pension.
“For example, someone planning to take a regular income from their drawdown plan after accessing their tax-free cash will likely choose a different asset allocation to someone who doesn’t plan to touch the remaining money for another 15 years.
“If you are planning to take a regular taxable income over and above your tax-free cash, you’ll also need to consider both the MPAA on your ability to save in the future and the sustainability of your withdrawal plan.
“While many will understandably be spooked at the idea of investing at the moment, it is worth remembering that short-term volatility has historically been the price you pay to enjoy longer-term growth.
“Investors also need to be aware of and comfortable with the risks they are taking. Although investments can go down in value as well as up – as we have seen in dramatic circumstances recently – the value of any investments left in cash will be eaten away by inflation over time,” he added.
